22 "Play More," Decoded
"Play more" is the stock answer to every improvement question. Korilak's 2016 guide opens by attacking it: it doesn't tell you what to play, and it doesn't separate good practice from bad. Tonehh's answer, years later, is that the phrase is right but compressed: it stands for the whole improvement process, which he unpacks into five connected principles. 4,31
Tonehh's five principles
- Play consistently, and take breaks. Keep accumulating hours over weeks and months instead of cramming: a few solid sessions every few days beat occasional binges or 30-minute dabbles. Stop when your fingers, hand, or eyes hurt. Bad days are short-term noise.
- Play around your level, and push past your comfort zone in moderation. Raise the star rating, try mods, turn on No Fail, and accept B and C ranks, but don't live above your level either, or you never reinforce the basics.
- Play a variety of skill sets, one at a time. Only one kind of map makes you good at only that kind, but trying everything at once reinforces nothing. Focus on one skill set for weeks or months, then rotate. Skills you set aside get rusty but come back quickly.
- Be intrinsically motivated. Notice small, concrete gains (a pass, a longer combo, fewer misses, better accuracy, a new mod) instead of waiting for rank and pp to tell you you're improving. Chasing rank is fine, but secondary.
- Enjoy the game for its own sake. Genuine enjoyment produces the other four naturally: steady play, breaks when it stops being fun, curiosity to experiment, and flow, the state of full absorption where self-consciousness fades and time flies.
His closing point: osu! is almost pure mechanics, with no strategic theory to study the way team games have. Improvement content, his own included, is reflection after the fact, and top players often can't explain how they improved beyond having kept playing.
Tonehh’s take: Practice habits
- Play consistently, but don't cram. Supported. Spaced practice and sleep both improve motor learning. Nuance: his example compares two-hour sessions every few days with 30 minutes daily, which also changes total practice time, while the spacing research holds total practice equal. 102,103
- Push past your comfort zone, in moderation. Supported. It's the challenge point framework in plain words. 108,109
- Use No Fail to practice above your level. Supported. It keeps you playing whole maps you can't pass yet; since January 2021 it costs pp only through misses, capped at 10%. 60
- One skill set for weeks rather than everything at once. Nuance. Lab studies often find that mixing tasks feels worse during practice but improves retention; many sport studies find the benefit small or absent. Those studies vary tasks within sessions, not across weeks. A middle ground: one main skill set for a stretch, with some variety in each session. 117,118,119
- Skills you set aside come back quickly. Supported. Relearning a motor skill is faster than learning it the first time, and physical and speed-based skills fade less with disuse than cognitive or accuracy-based ones; skills do still decay, substantially after a year or more. 120,121,122
Tonehh’s take: Mindset
- Intrinsic motivation first; rank goals are fine but secondary. Supported. A 40-year meta-analysis found that intrinsic motivation predicts performance and that external incentives can coexist with it. 123
- pp reworks happen every few months. Nuance. Recent official updates came in September 2024, March 2025, October 2025, and July 2026, roughly six to eight months apart. 76,77,78,79
- Being hardstuck is an illusion. Partly supported. Practice curves show big early gains that shrink over time, and individual curves often show plateaus that break when the learner changes approach. But gains do slow toward imperceptible rates. 124,125,126
- Enjoyment and flow drive the best play. Partly supported. Flow's features match his description, and a meta-analysis found a medium-sized link between flow and performance, without settling which causes which. 127,128
- Enjoying the game and being hooked on it are different. Supported. The WHO defines gaming disorder by impaired control, gaming taking priority over the rest of life, and continuing despite harm, usually for at least 12 months. 168
- Theory is an afterthought. Partly supported. Skills are built by doing, and rule-heavy learning can break down under stress, but how you practice (difficulty, spacing, sleep) changes how much you learn. That's the fair role for a book like this: shaping practice and diagnosing problems, not replacing play. 103,108,129,130
ScarletStory’s take
- Playing purely to get better is a reason to quit. Supported. His first entry is not mechanical: players who chase skill by force of will, rather than by enjoying the game, burn out when improvement turns out to be slow. Let skill come to you. Intrinsic motivation predicts performance, and the former world number one's entire advice to new players was two words (Ch. 25). 24,72,123
- The only person worth impressing is yourself. Agrees with the top players. The same conclusion the 2026 interviews reach from the other end of the leaderboard (Ch. 24). 40,72
- Practising a mistake makes you better at the mistake. Supported. Repeating a movement biases later movements toward it, which is the mechanism behind finger lock and behind every habit this book asks you to fix early rather than late (Ch. 6). His rule: learn it right the first time, even when right is harder. 72,111,112
Korilak’s take
- "Play more" doesn't distinguish good practice from bad; routines and strategies make practice efficient. Supported. Accumulated practice explains about a quarter of skill differences in games in one large meta-analysis (critics say more), and how practice is structured changes how much it teaches. 31,108,150,151
bloo’s take
- "Play more" mostly fits new players; after that, practice your specific weaknesses. Agrees with the chart. For any skill, his answer is the tennis one: to get better at tennis, play tennis. 14
- A new skill feels awful at first; top players push through it anyway. Supported. Performance drops when practice gets harder, even while learning improves. He learned Easy from a point where he couldn't read AR 8, after a summer of improvement podcasts hosted by Happystick. 108
Tonehh’s take
- Practicing one skill set indirectly trains others. Partly supported. His speed training stalled for two months until a few weeks of nomod streams, which trained stamina, flow aim, and finger control, broke the wall. RyuK makes the same point about deathstream stamina carrying over to burst and stream speed. Related skills share components, as the chart's arrows show, but no study has measured this in osu!. 11
Finished this chapter?
Log in to track progressMark it complete for 🍪 100 and track your way to Codex Graduate.
Community discussion
Discussion is not evidence: it never changes the chapter directly. Corrections go through Codex suggestions, where they're checked against sources.
Forum threads about this chapterStart one
None yet — longer questions and write-ups belong in the forums, where they stay findable.